Sofa webbing vs springs reddit. Professional furniture designer here.

Sofa webbing vs springs reddit Metals clips slot in and you weave the webbing. Aug 9, 2024 · Comparing Sofa Webbing and Springs. If the webbing is re-stretched and springs re-tied there shouldn't be a need for springs inside the cushions. If there were no springs then there may be (elastic) webbing on the top instead. There are no springs … although it’s funny, because it really looks like there’s an under-layer of cambric and webbing below the main webbing with a cavity between them, which seems like just the kind of space where you’d find some springs maybe. What looks like carpet padding to you is a layer of thick, tough material that protects the seat foam from the S springs and helps to distribute the weight of the person so they don't feel the S springs. The 3 most common in order of best to worst (usually) are eight way hand tied, sinuous or "no sag" springs, and webbing. Apr 22, 2016 · The springs are supported by webbing on the bottom of the sofa (steel webbing is best, but other materials may be used) and the top of the springs are secured by twine. 0 figuring the pillow top would counteract some of the firmness of the higher density cushion and that the higher density would hold up better as the sofa aged. But have a few concerns: Not sure if the frame built for webbing (pulling in) would structurally support springs (pushing out) Overall my takeaway ended up being that for future furniture (new or repaired) I may lean towards webbing over springs. If it is, flip the sofa forward onto it's knees and unstaple the fabric on the bottom. Dive into expert insights and key factors for choosing the perfect support system for your couch. If you come with a higher budget--over £325--and a need to support kids, pets and lots of activity, choose spring construction. The Insider's Guide to Furniture states "High quality, non-stretchable Pirelli webbing, when properly installed by a skilled craftsperson, should last 20 years and more. And you can be sure it's made of hardwood with screws instead of staples. The update: I did manage to get the springs installed, but after doing a cost/benefit analysis on the remaining time and energy I had left, I'm taking the L on salvaging this guy and looking for alternative resting options. This varies of course when you add the wrapping to it for instance, Dacron or Trillium like I like to use. Solid hardwood is obviously best, but those get heavy and pricy fast. Doesn’t bode well for long term. Feb 24, 2023 · Hand-tied springs are ideal for high-end furniture that will be used for many years, as they provide superior comfort and durability. At least for the seat if possible. Posted by u/40high - 3 votes and 1 comment You don’t take all the webbing off at once, especially if you have springs because the webbing holds the tension of springs. Pic of sofa frame with S springs. solid wood and metal construction, with a webbing seat suspension. 25” frame, or just slightly inside the box. The rest of the upholstery is in good condition and I’d like to avoid redoing it. 90 degree cut that's 1/2in deep on the webbing support/sofa frame. Remove all the webbing and start from scratch? See full list on nytimes. There’s so much that goes into the perfect couch but if you want something that will be comfortable for a long time, please do not get an ikea couch! The prices were not much lower than Mor furniture but way worse in quality/comfort. Have you considered finding a local upholstery shop? The one near me also makes furniture from scratch. While in IKEA, I saw another sofa (Ektorp) which looks very similar and is almost the same price. I have learned that performance fabric would be best, but wife would like a softer feel to the fabric (no to any suedes as the wife does not like being able to see the hand swipe marks, hope that makes sense). Cut some 1" thick high density foam (I didn't check the link in this post but it seems fine) to the size of the cushion and slide it behind the sinuous springs or nylon webbing, depending which you've Finding the same sofa (it’s the Signature Design by Ashley Megginson 2-Piece Sectional in Storm) on another website it said the frame was constructed of hardwoods and plywood’s. Still have the chaise section to do & thinking springs might be an upgrade. 87K subscribers in the upholstery community. The cushions have springs in them like how a mattress does and they aren't sagging or showing any signs of wear and I am on the large and heavy side. I'm fixing a 2 part section couch that has started to sag a ton over the last 6 months. Research these. ) I have a Karlstad sofa circa 2009 that I’ve repaired the arm/leg assembly on, but the core cushions and springs are still in great condition. I bought the Ashby sofa 2 years ago and we had an issue down the road and they replaced the whole couch under warranty with no hassle and the new one is great too. This consists consists of double conical springs knotted eight times each with premium twine, which is secured to the frame. There are plenty of videos on how to use this as well. Buy a webbing stretcher. They actually make Pirelli webbing from a combination of both woven nylon fabric and rubber. not with it for 20 years yet, but it gets a lot of use and it is really solid. IDK what sort of fabric you're getting for a $1500 reupholstery quote but that's suspiciously cheap. Buy a staple gun. Coil springs take up far more space than webbing. Since there is a pillow top on the cushion, I was leaning towards the 3. Choose wisely for a cozy seating experience! Springs in seat cushions can provide long-lasting support, but sometimes those cushions have a firmer feeling. 5 hour movie on one? Feb 7, 2020 · Sofa Spring Systems Comparison Eight-Way Handtied You have spotted a sofa that looks so beautiful that you act on emotion and buy it right away, well friends we are here to educate you so you know what to look for when buying sofas and similar products. Finally, incorporating the second layer of webbing over the first layer and place the cushions back. Results 1 to 7 of 7 Thread: 8-way hand tied construction vs. However, it sounds like webbing falls into either great or terrible, and unfortunately there isn't much out there that describes what the difference is from a maker's prospective. From what I was reading online the problem was more likely to be the frame or a broken spring(s), however taking off the dust cover has shown all of the springs are attached and not broken . We're going to call some places Monday to see if they even do 8 way ties at all or just how much re-webbing would be. Except that Jute is garbage. The shape of these frame supports in the picture will help reduce chance of warp on your frame. com Mar 4, 2022 · In general, webbing makes a sofa more affordable than springs because the material is inexpensive and it's quick and easy to install. For those that have one, few questions: PO replaced webbing with plywood board and the furniture was so uncomfortable no matter how thick the foam cushions were. You can pick a design, level of padding, and fabric or leather; it's custom down to the height and depth of the seat. If you bought a higher quality brand from an upscale furniture dealer, you'd be paying way more than $5,000. When deciding between sofa webbing and springs, you’ll want to consider factors like comfort, durability, and cost to make an informed choice that suits your preferences. Sofa webbing offers a comfortable seating experience by distributing weight evenly across the surface. Anyway, some of the springs are popping out, so I bought some upholstery clips, I’ve screwed one in and now I can’t attach the spring on the other side as I can’t stretch it enough (my purple thumb will attest to that) several of the other plastic clips are pulling out as well, I was thinking I’m looking into getting a long lead for beginning off leash/loose heel training for my 5 month old golden retriever puppy. Unfortunately I have no experience with Mantle. that might be the weakest link, we'll see. We've been super impressed with the sofa and the customer service from Article. " Low quality webbing (and/or less of it) could sag in a few years. Like would you want to sit down and watch a 2. As they are tied they are pulled into their permanent position to give the chair or sofa its shape. Sinuous spring construction tends to fall in the middle of the price range, while eight-way, hand-tied springs are usually the most expensive option. However, webbing is a better choice for budget-friendly furniture or for those who are looking for an easier DIY upholstery project. The springs underneath are attached using some sort of metal clip that goes through the webbing. The Fabric It has hand tied springs supported by jute webbing. I stripped away the old stuff that was disintegrating and so haphazard (photos) but I don’t want to just wing it and have it end up haphazard again. it is much easier to watch a video than to explain. Made with strong webbing and springs. I would also check the quality of the webbing. If used in low profile modern sofas or sectionals, the coil springs would be visible below the seats . Though often called “rubber webbing” or “nylon webbing”, neither name is quite accurate. Fabric to be suitable for small dog breeds and children. It’s fairly simple to do but the hard part is most of the time you have to de-staple part of the sofa to gain access to do any repairs. Posted by u/stanley_morgan - 1 vote and 1 comment No problem. Sep 6, 2023 · In conclusion, both zigzag springs and webbing have their own advantages and disadvantages. Upholstery Webbing Chair Couch Material Replacement,Elastic Webbing Latex Band, Stretchy Spring Alternative, Furniture Repair DIY Elasbelt 2" Wide (10m/32ft). Comfort and Feel. The webbing is what supports the springs. The webbing below the springs was secured with tacks which are falling out, and the webbing itself is not in good condition. These are simple relatively new chairs, from like Crate and Barrel, or similar. Next, weave the sofa’s frame with new elastic webbing and secure it by using a stapler. I plan to have a platform of webbing at the bottom of the box, then springs, all tied together at the top (I understand there will be a learning curve on doing this right), followed by the cushions. Flexolator you just replace the whole box. A higher density is of course, longer lasting foam, but ILD is all about firmness/softness. Learn about construction, durability, comfort, and more to make an informed choice that suits your preferences and budget. Thanks. #shorts #short #supercub #aviation #aviationlovers #comfort #upholstery Our webbing is built with your back in mind! Get rid of the springs and use our webbi I hate furniture shopping and am happy to pay a bit more for durability/quality so I don't have to get dragged to the showrooms w/ my partner. Most of the low to mid range items are getting to the point where they're disposable furniture (poor springs or using webbing for the seat, MDF frames, etc). After my initial research, I've seen jute webbing recommended (as it's stronger than elastic webbing). But the OG webbing was rubber, and a VERY loose weave, so maybe the doesn’t computer anyway. The couch was manufactured with green/black elastic webbing and it's lost its integrity. You want them close together. After some back and forth between IKEA and Wayfair, I shortlisted the UPPLAND sofa and drove to IKEA last night to try it. Both are similar, differences are Lovesac uses springs & webbing, plywood over OS strandboard, similar strength, more fabric choices, and higher in price. OK, so if we go with the Omnia sofa, the next question is whether to get the 2. Then the tops are tied with four strong cords running across the top of each spring. Surface area - A sofa with two seat cushions or deeper seat cushions will last longer than the same size sofa with 3 seat cushions or narrower seat cushions Amount of use - The more time you spend on the sofa, the sooner the cushions will wear out. I imagine the cushions sitting just at the top of the 6. That’s where the name comes in—the twine is tied by hand at eight different spots for each spring and then attached to the frame. Lol. Moser Fahmida. It works well until the seat foam begins to Yup, holds pretty well. Put your front to back webbing on first. Usually a suspension described only as webbing does not have any springs. springs. For Cozylant sofas, we use a combination of zigzag springs and webbings to provide you with the best of both worlds But mostly you see the S springs. The eight way hand tied is the the best, but a good sinuous can be almost if not as good and will typically cost significantly less. It has been redone at least once before - there are smaller tacks still in the frame. You do NOT want webbing or flexolater/grid. It's not a high quality piece of furniture as far as I can tell, I know replacing the webbing is best for long term but I'm looking for an easy, short term DIY fix. I suggest if you are going to go this route to do this first! Don't tie your springs if the webbing is loose or else you will end up doing it again. I know that Ashley sofas aren’t even remotely top of the line but my current sofa is completely and utterly done for and we need to replace it soon. A "good" sofa should be at least 9,000 to 15,000 double rubs. While many other companies make this webbing today, most people in the industry still call it Pirelli webbing. Arhaus basically said too bad. I'm a garment sewer and quilter, but I am confident in my box cushion sewing skills. The webbing is in tact but stretched out, and I don't know that I'm confident enough to remove all of the old webbing. I’ll try to find this YouTube vid of a father and son showing how to replace the webbing… Suspension/Foundation: in a traditional sofa or loveseat, the gold standard has been Eight-Way Hand-Tied suspension. Sinuous Springs vs. I am in the US and am looking for advice on a sofa purchase. Sinuous springs are just as durable ask any manufacturer it's just how you space them & gauge used. Possibly coils, but that would fall in with the tying issue. 20 votes, 13 comments. Sinuous wire springs (You can increase the strength here by adding webbing on the frame but that’s a hack that I know literally no one else who’s even thought of doing it. You didn't mention the height of the frame support. Got a second hand Ikea Friheten sofa, would probably advise against it, but got it super cheap. I have purchased elastic webbing, seatbelt style webbing and jute. I've removed some staples from the fabric at the bottom that hides the insides and I can see the webbing. Basically, the burlap/ dacron creates a buffer to contain your springs from rubbing through your cushions. And you’ll want to do one at a time so you’re slowly replacing each piece so it stays structurally the same. Then the long side to side. How to Replace Sofa Elastic Webbing? You can replace the sofa elastic webbing by removing the cushions, then remove the damaged webbing by removing its clip. So we have these sofas that are sagging. Oct 18, 2024 · Discover the ultimate showdown between webbing and springs for sofa support systems in this insightful article. This coil spring system is used in brands like Smith Brothers of Berne, Indiana. Professional furniture designer here. You can also put webbing between the springs if it starts to sag. For the price, it's unbeatable. As for the webbing, you could take it loose and re-tighten this as well, with a webbing stretcher. Today we identified the type of springs in the seats — a flexonator grid type, with springs sort of like trampoline springs. I did the chair in elastic first but didn’t have the webbing stretcher tool and when I sat in it I almost hit the floor because I couldn’t get it tight Webbing or mesh in place of springs is the lowest-quality option. but it is easily repairable if anything goes wrong with it, and all of the cushions are removable Regarding type of use, placement of sofa - utilized in a living room, in a bungalow, with three residents and ample excess seating (not only the sofa available for comfortable seating) realistically speaking, it does not receive a ton of use I'd guess around 4x a week someone is on the sofa for an hour or so - I have owned the pottery barn I’m in the middle of tackling my first upholstery project by replacing the webbing in our chairs, but now that I need to buy more webbing, I’m worried I made the wrong choice and my webbing on the first two chairs is too weak. Hello! I’m hoping to get some advice on how to go about webbing together these springs. I've only had various Ikea sofas for a few years and a good experience with a Jordan Alexander Interior Designs sofa made in Granite Falls, North Carolina. Reply reply GA_peach_in_TX For context, the main reason I'm considering a sofa bed is for guests to have something comfortable to sleep on - but I'm wondering what the tradeoffs are if I decide to get a sofa customized with the sofa bed. Springs. Thank you for saying this! We bought a Lipton and it is the least comfortable sofa ever! My husband said “it is not the same as the one we sat on in the store”. If you compare a $400 sofas springs vs a 2k sofas springs I bet you see twice as many S springs in it and 3 or 4 horizontal bars connecting them vs 1 or 2 in the cheap sofa. So you would go with 36 but you have only seen it used with springs? I think the sofa has rubber webbing. And if the springs are capped with a layer of foam, the foam density remains relevant. The seats are extra-firm (like sitting on a board) and there is no pitch built into the seat. Polyester webbing has high UV resistance and strength. If you have Reddit is a network of communities where people can dive into their interests, hobbies and passions. For the highest quality that you can reupholster in 20 years, you're looking for a bench made sofa constructed from hardwood probably with 8-way hand-tied springs, though sinuous springs are improving (depends on the wire gauge). 0 or 3. Just use Pereli Rubber and Osborn Clips. But everything I see or read seems to take the type of cord as a given. you can see some of them starting to twist a little. If you look at same on par quality sofas as Mitchell & Gold & RH. Jul 2, 2024 · Discover the ultimate showdown between sofa springs and webbing in couch construction! Unravel the debate on comfort, durability, versatility, and cost-effectiveness to make an informed decision. They’re light but break really easily and you’ll be buying a new sofa in a few years. Three new cushions, all new batting, and at least a dozen yards of fabric (have you priced good upholstery fabric?), plus all that cording or gimp, PLUS refinishing the frame and retying the Modern upholstered furniture styles are more streamlined than classic traditional seating. Both can be good, springs aren't necessarily better though they're sometimes marketed that way. same experience here with my Cade sofa from room and board. It is about 90% as durable as nylon, and it is one of the most UV-stable webbings available. 0 density cushions. Open menu Open navigation Go to Reddit Home Jan 10, 2025 · Technical Building wood seat base webbing vs sofa springs. My preferences are as follows: - $2000 budget - 80" to 90"- 3 seats - Leather (first choice is full grain, second choice is "full" top grain - I want it to be breathable and develop a patina) Hi folks! I'm looking at finally getting a long-lasting sofa, and I've been fond of my Room & Board armchairs, so I'm looking at their stuff. I'd build boxes out of ply, put firm 4" on top and firm 1" on all the sides and sew the upholstery together and slip it over with the help of some super thin plastic then staple underneath and add dustcover and feet. The springs may not sag, but they do squeak and snap fittings after 10 years, also put uneven pressure on the foam and will cut through from underneath over time. How the cushions are used - If you usually lie down, the cushions will last longer. Webbing - Webbing: This is a less expensive support system made from elastic or synthetic straps woven across the sofa frame. A commercial sofa (like in your hotel room) is 20,000 - 30,000, while extra heavy duty (like airports, public transportation, hospital waiting rooms) maybe 30,000 double rubs or more. Dig through photos of mid century modern sofa webbing. Less confident in the structural furniture elements, though! If the springs are in bad shape, is it possible to replace them with webbing? It needs refinishing, not just reupholstery. Hello, I have a sofa that is sagging a bit on both sides. We took the credit as we could live with the cosmetic imperfection. Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next > This includes chip core frames, no springs (or webbing) in the foundation and low cost foam cushions. It has wood crosspieces in the middle of the seat and one could honestly sustain a minor bruise if they sat down too enthusiastically in that spot with the current cushions. However I'm just wondering if a couch with cushions placed on a platform would be noticeably less comfortable than a typical couch with springs. Hi all, I moved to a new place with my girlfriend and we set a budget of $450 for a Sofa. Pocketed Coils Hi r/upholstery!We are slowly beginning work on our giant couch project — a 1970’s Broyhill modular sectional. You can find cheaper good quality, imported sofas around but they'll have lower foam density, webbing suspension, pine, Alder or rubberwood frames, hardly any down or spring down cushion options, and less quality spring suspension, & fabric choices. Any ideas or suggestions welcome. It doesn't stretch much, even in water. Seating to be Coiled/Springs for longer lasting seating. In conclusion, both hand-tied springs and webbing have their benefits and Bought new clips and nylon elastic webbing, cut all webbing to size, attached the clips, (a major task) I tried using a vise to squeeze these clips as thin as I could, but ended up using pliers as they were more able to get a tighter squeeze than the vise. In particular, I'm looking at the Metro sofa (non-sectional variant) and am curious if any of y'all have experience hosting tall/heavy guests on these (for sitting and/or sleeping). Similar styles The support for the cushions is either webbing or springs. Make sure you ask for high density upholstery foam with the longest possible lifespan and it will remain bouncy for 20 years if used regularly. Posted by u/HoboHaxor - 1 vote and no comments I'm a novice in upholstery. Yeah it is great. There are "nicer" versions from Room and Board (metal suspension vs pirelli webbing), but they're also double the price. I'm not sure what kind of furniture you're making, but I would recommend doing eight-way hand tied springs instead of zig zag spring. I’m currently using a 3 ft. Buy a role of jute webbing. You probably won't find many co's with this level of customization. I pull it tight with a webbing tool. Ooh, yes that's a long sofa. That'll give you access to the underside of the seat deck. I have a leather sofa and one seat sags. Discussion in 'The Hokey Ass Message Board' started by Duke, Jan 10, 2025. A great example is the Room & Board Ericson Sofa vs. It's really clever what they came up with in the sixties. Then burlap, and then I would do a rolled edge around the outside and a layer of rubberized hair under the foam since there’s so much space between the springs on the outside, Plus the rubberized hair will protect the foam from the ends of the springs/clips. Yeah- 24" sinuous springs are too long. Is there any easy way to tell what's failing? String, coils, webbing, or any combination. Arhaus costs less. I get how to staple and stretch webbing to the bottom of a normal squared off bottom frame. Metal or Pirelli (rubber) webbing/banding supports the bottom. Skip to main content. Might be easier than you think to work with sofa webbing. I have the jute webbing (red) for my project and was going to web the seat and back of this chair to get it to a point where I could upholster but I am at an absolute loss on if I can just use webbing. And on the edges of the seat you want two together so you don’t fall into the sofa. I feel like the springs on the edges seem to have less play compared to the more central ones As the springs flex they will rub against whatever is touching them. I’d like to let her wander around, sniff and check stuff out while still having control over her if What type of string/twine/cord do you use to tie springs? Experimenting with a Marshall spring unit to see if tying it together helps its performance, sort of similarly to hand tied seat springs. These are not very common and I wanted to share a picture to the For a simple sofa at a low price point around £325 (in 2010 dollars), webbing is a fine choice when the sofa only needs to stand up to comfortable, occasional use. But if we just need to redo the jute webbing, that seems doable. If the only problem is that the webbing has failed, and the internal springs are OK, this is not too difficult of a fix for a DIY project. It's just barely antique, could be as late as late 1930s. There's a community for whatever you're interested in on Reddit. Eight-Way Handtied Spring Suspension System is comprised of coil Polyester is a common choice for webbing in the outdoor industry because it is strong, does not stretch, is UV-stable, and does not absorb water. I use a tool that has the spikes in it so I get it fairly There’s some mark-up applied at the store for sure; difference in furniture price isn’t completely correlated to overall quality, but it can be a much better bellwether for quality of materials (or complexity of manufacturing) than other products. Webbing suspension systems are very Repairs can be done but finding matching ones creates delays. I’ll try and keep it simple because it really is a can of worms lol Frame. Look up 8-way tie. For more support. Unusual method of tying the springs, but otherwise it is exactly how it should be. It looks like most professional sofas either use a system of springs or webbing. With this system, a series of coil springs are hand-tied into a secure position that adds an incredible level of durability and creates a supportive and comfortable surface. Sep 27, 2024 · This week, I am replacing the elastic webbing in this fixed cushion leather sofa. Generally if your couch has nice foam and a nice frame, it'll have nice cushion support. Doesn't have a lot of give. The belt has never came undone or failed me. Springs on bottom are popping out due to torn webbing and I have bought replacement jute webbing. A low density foam cap will compress and you'll be able to feel those springs pressing into your backside. I work in a psych hospital as a psychologist for kids and teens and physical fights are pretty common. It is a wood framed couch with metal slats and springs underneath, that originally had box cushions. But because these are curved, the squared off edge where the jute ends are tacked or stapled in is recessed inward from the curvy pieces of the frame. Zigzag springs offer excellent support and durability, while webbing might provide a more flexible and comfortable seating experience. Welcome to My Furniture Forum, sponsored by The Keeping Room, a dealer in high quality leather and reproduction furniture. The biggest problem is that many people find that the furniture just isn't very comfortable, even when new. So I go to put the straps on the loveseat, but they’re all too thick to fit into the slots. . Posted by u/Axtor - 2 votes and 2 comments The new webbing is much better for sitting, but if I fall asleep in it then I wake up sunk in pretty far. Don’t buy a Kipton sofa if you want a comfortable sofa. I would definitely tie the springs a bit, even if they weren’t originally tied. - Comparison: Sinuous springs are more durable and supportive than webbing, which can lose elasticity and sag over time. Avoid OSB or “chip board” frames. High and low quality webbing look very similar to the untrained eye, but have different properties. Expand user menu Open settings menu Jackson Catnapper uses pocket coils cushions and sinuous springs, and goes a step further with a steel box spring frame, and an additional helper coil below them. For Cozylant sofas, we use a combination of zigzag springs and webbings to provide you with the best of both worlds As you can see, any time you put foam on top of S springs the S springs will cut through the foam. the Thos. I think I could more reasonably do webbing vs. I always remove the zigzag springs and use 3" elastic webbing, it lasts so much longer and gives an even smooth comfort level across the sofa. We purchased the protective care and reached out to the store and the company directly. There are most likely springs in the base of the couch under the cushions anyway. Also, if it’s a bench cushion versus multiple seat cushions, oh and then the foundation which is the type of springs or webbing underneath. Dec 6, 2024 · Sinuous Springs vs. And weave away. They creak less, not as flexible, but can be replaced easier. I have diy and woodworking experience. I help run a furniture repair company and have to remove these springs all the time. Here is one of many videos on youtube that show you what to do. The springs are sewn to a base of stretched webbing. Jan 27, 2022 · One of the best coil springs on the market today is the 8-way hand-tied coil spring. Staple burlap on top to support the foam or cotton, then cover. leash for regular walks. A very good quality home sofa should survive 15,000 - 20,000 double rubs. pxh oegn juckw ajbgws imkclmz ufr llvlk bzwsjyd pxl tagbre xdrsf uhcqiy jjpl xuzkmv loyy